Column
Dry Eyes and Corneal Refractive Therapy

Hardly a day goes by without a patient reporting symptoms of dryness
when wearing soft contact lenses. In 2005, Nichols et al reported that
52% of contact lens wearers reported having dry eyes at some time
throughout their contact lens wearing schedule. This number was
found to be 12 times higher than that of emmetropes requiring no
ocular correction. Therefore, it is not surprising that the most
frequently reported reason for soft lens dissatisfaction and
discontinuation is dry eye-related symptoms.

So how do we manage our contact lens patients who are unable to
obtain adequate comfort and/or wearing time secondary to dryness?
Step one is always the same: rule out the possibility of the preserved
lens care products as the source of the symptoms. This is often
accomplished by switching the patient to daily disposable lenses or
initiating a preservative-free disinfection system such as hydrogen
peroxide.

If the dry eye symptoms continue, you can then begin a regimen of
dry eye treatments that may include preservative-free artificial tear
therapy, omega-3 supplements, lid hygiene, ocular anti-inflammatory
agents and punctual occlusion. However, even with maximum dry eye
therapies, some CL patients continue to experience dry eye
symptoms.

Many of these patients seek to resolve their contact lens failure by
pursuing refractive surgery, but patients need to be cautioned that
laser surgery can adversely affect tear production and that patients
with preexisting dry eyes are at a higher risk of developing significant
post-operative dry eye complications. Over the years, we and others
have reported some success in successfully managing these patients’
refractive errors with corneal refractive therapy.

One such individual is a 28-year-old female with a refractive error of
-3.50D sphere in the right eye and -3.75D sphere in her left eye. She
had a four-year history of dry eyes with contact lenses despite
numerous attempts with a wide range of daily disposable lenses and
appropriate dry eye therapies. The patient was free of any corneal or
conjunctival pathology, and she reported that her dry eye symptoms
were significantly reduced when she wore her spectacle correction.
However, she insisted that glasses were not an option for her lifestyle.
She was an avid runner and biker and, in the rainy Pacific Northwest
of the USA, glasses are a significant problem.





















Patient’s post-fitting corneal topography and fluorescein photos.


It was at that time that we suggested the possibility of contact lens
corneal reshaping.  Clinical experience has taught us that some dry
eye patients do exceptionally well with the overnight reshaping
therapy. The closed eye environment may prevent excessive tear
evaporation, a contributing cause of dry eye symptoms in some
contact lens wearers. With the overnight reshaping modality, many
patients report improved daily comfort since no corrective device is on
their eyes throughout the day to stress the tear film.  

The patient was successfully fitted with Paragon CRT lenses, and
within seven days her uncorrected visual acuity was a stable 20/20 or
1.0 throughout her waking hours. The patient reported no overnight
ocular discomfort with the lenses and no dry eye symptoms
throughout the day.

We believe that a number of contact lens-induced dry eye patients
may be excellent candidates for corneal reshaping. This is especially
true for those individuals considering surgical intervention as a
refractive treatment.    


Reference:
http://www.iovs.org/content/46/6/1911.abstract
Patrick Caroline is an
associate professor
of optometry at
Pacific University and
a consultant to
Paragon Vision
Sciences.